With many of you wanting to swap engines on your s12's, i thought it would be a good idea to post up this article i found in the first issue of Project Car Magazine, about the myths and guidelines that comes with purchasing an engineset or clip.
Its Hip to Clip
Giving you the skinny on buying used JDM motors
by. Tyrone Rodrigues (project car magazine, issue 1)
Flipping burgers and slangin' mix cds on the sidewalk has finally paid off. In only three short years you've saved enough money to get that sweet JDM engine swap. No longer will friends mock your slow ass ride -- now they'll ridicule your lack of fashion sense and your grotesque eating habits. Nothing short of a small fortune, clips and complete engines can be a helluva lotta fun or the bane of your existence depending on whether or not you get stuck with a lemon.
A Japanese clip or complete engine is serious money, especially for a broke mofo like you and us. Just like any other important decision, it's wise to have a complete understanding of what exactly you're getting yourself into before you spend this year's college tuition. Putting in the tiniest amount of effort to source a good supplier and clip will go far in the long run. C'mon, would you rather drive your car or tow it? Lets get some JDM urban myths out of the way. Shall we?
Japanese motors are driven 40,000 miles or less
'
There is no Japanese law that requires an engine be removed at 40,000 miles (let's not forget that Japan goes by kilometers). Nor is there a law that forces cars off the road at that mileage. It's ridiculous that some shops and importers even suggest this; If your would-be importer mentions this ask for proof or better yet, go somewhere else.
The closest regulation that Japan has to the 40k myth is the infamous Shaken (pronounced with a long "a") -- a combination of hefty taxes and vehicle inspection. The mandatory Shaken becomes a biennial affair after a vehicle's third birthday. To make matters worse, as a deterrent to keep older vehicles off the road, the Shaken increases with age of the vehicle. And you though smogging a vehicle here is bad.
JDM Engines Haven't Been Driven Hard
Yeah, that's why so many clips come with front mounted intercoolers and intakes, homie. So the reality is that engine mods technically break the rules of Shaken, but that doesn't stop our Japanese brethren. Many shops and tuners keep stock parts around for popular vehicles. Their customers stop by before their Shaken certification, swap back to stock, keep the man happy, and swap their good stuff back on. Sound familiar? That's why you're often better off with a stock clip versus one with "free" extra parts. Those extra parts might cost more in the long run since the previous owner beat the shit out of the car.
So don't fool yourself: nobody buys an NSX, Skyline GTR, Silvia, RX-7, or Type R to drive it like your mom. Japanese laws and police aren't as hardcore as our anal bean counters and steroid-fed ex-high school bullies. Many of these cars were either regularly tracked or spend a lot of street time going faster then the speed limit, not slower. Why do you think so many clips have dents dings and missing body panels? they've come right off wrecked cars.
My New Engine is Street Legal as Long as It's Newer then the Chassis
The EPA's main issue with engine swaps has to do with pollution. Emissions controls between Japan and the US differ significantly, such as the lack of EGRs. Japanese fuel computers are also tuned for their gas. If you plan on swapping out to a JDM motor, be prepared to do "special smogs". Of course, vehicles with a model year 1974 or before are exempt across the country
Generally speaking the man doesn't look too kindly on engine swaps. This is particularly true if you're dropping in a mill that was never offered or legalized for North America. Just because states other then California might be lax or don't know what to check for doesn't mean that your SR20DET is actually road legal. As a rule of thumb, however, if it's legal in California, the its probably legal in the rest of the country in the eyes of the EPA
What to Watch For
- How Complete is the Clip?-
It sounds silly, right? You pay thousands for a motor set or clip and would expect it to be complete down to the last relay. Sometimes they're not and you need to know what you're getting. A complete engine means you don't have to go search for a mass air flow meter, coil packs, or intercooler piping in the middle of a swap job
Be sure that whoever you buy the engine from has the same definition of complete as you do. When we say a complete engine we mean everything necessary for a turn key swap. Typically a complete engine's major components include the engine itself, the transmission and uncut harness. Notice we said uncut harness -- anything else and you are in for a world of hurt.
Avoid at all costs, motor sets that have been parted together. We once saw a S15 Silvia SR20DET come into a shop with a S13 turbo and manifold, S14 tranny, and a S15 naturally aspirated wiring harness. If you know anything about your SR, you'll know that these aren't really compatible. The shop's suggestion to the customer was to sell everything off, take a loss, and buy a complete motor. Don't let this happen to you.
Additionally, be smart about where you shop. If you're getting a full front clip, that can frequently include the front brakes and suspension. Sometimes it doesn't but check around; one supplier might offer more for the same price. Many JDM vehicles have larger, beefier and generally better brakes then their US counterparts. If it doesn't come with the clip, ask for it -- you might not get it for free, but you can definitely work out a deal since you're already spending a grip
What's the Condition of the Engine?
Remember that these engines have been beat on regularly. Anything that's less then five years old is usually okay to drop right in, but that doesn't mean removing the valve cover or checking the oilpan is a bad idea -- we highly suggest it. Engines over five years old are going to have more mileage then a brand spanking new motor. If the supplier is comfortable showing you the engine, check the spark plugs and the condition of the oil or leftover radiator fluid. Watch out for fouled plugs, sludgy oil, or a mixture of oil and water in the radiator; they're all very bad signs. You'll want to see as much of the engine as you can before putting down a deposit.
If you decide to get an older engine, don't assume that it's bulletproof. You might be better off rebuilding it from the get-go. If you have a reputable engine builder that you trust near you, the peace of mind from knowing the engine was rebuilt and has good compression is worth the additional dough.
Clips on eBay
This one is real simple. Don't do it. If you can't inspect the motor before you buy it, its worse than going on a date with a chick off Myspace with no picture posted (shudder)
Damage
Remember, most of the clips you encounter were in some kind of accident. It's vital to take a close look at where the car was hit. If it was hit in the rear it usually isn't a big deal - unless that where the engine is, like with an MR2. If the vehicle was hit in the front, you must evaluate how much damage the front end has taken. Has this caused any leaks? Were any vital components, such as intercooler piping or the wiring harness, damaged? Sometimes the damage can be considerable enough that the clip is a complete loss.
Conclusion
That's it. You're armed with a great starting point or knowledge. Although we've given you a bunch of stuff to watch out for, remember that a great number of engine suppliers are in the business to stay in business. You hopefully wont have to kill yourself to find the engine that you want, but be picky, take your time, and learn up -- it's your money and you want to get what you pay for.
Sources:
ASAP Motors - www.asapmotors.com
G-Dimension - www.g-dimension.com
Japanese Engine Importers - www.japaneseengineimport.com
JDM Addiction - www.jdmaddiction.com
Project Silvia - www.projectsilva.com
TWS - www.thewheelsupply.com
Aug 28, 2008, 12:43 am · #1